The Cutthroat Nature of MLB Contracts

In comparison to other major sports leagues, MLB contracts often stand out for their sheer size and scope, reflecting both the popularity of baseball in the United States and the significant revenue it generates. These contracts, which can run into hundreds of millions of dollars, not only signify the financial muscle of the MLB but also highlight the unique aspects of baseball's salary structure and player valuation. From guaranteed money and free agency to arbitration and bonuses, the dynamics of MLB contracts offer a compelling insight into the economics of the sport, revealing how teams invest in talent and how players secure their futures in this lucrative arena.

Entry to Professional Baseball

Most players enter the MLB through the amateur draft and are offered initial contracts by the team that drafted them. These contracts are typically minor league deals that bind the player to the minor league team and are often much smaller than major league contracts. From Rookie to Triple-A, the salary range is $4,800 - $35,000. The player may also be offered a signing bonus to incentivize striking a deal with the team that drafted them. These can be millions of dollars in the first round but sharply decline later on.

First Years in the MLB

Once a player is added to the 40-man roster and makes their MLB debut, they enter the pre-arbitration phase. A player needs three years of MLB service time to be eligible for arbitration. A full year of service time equals 172 days on the active roster or injured list During these years, the team decides the player's salary, which must be at least the MLB minimum ($720,000). Although uncommon, some teams may pay a player more than the MLB minimum if their performance is outstanding or they want to give goodwill for future negotiations.


After accumulating three years of service time (or qualifying as a "Super Two" with top 22% service time among players with more than two but less than three years), players are eligible for salary arbitration. In arbitration, players and teams submit salary figures, and if they can’t agree, an arbitrator decides the player's salary based on performance, comparables, and other factors. The arbitrator will choose the number proposed by either the player/agent or the team, and not a compromise. This is often a controversial practice, with the player trying to oversell himself while the team tries to undervalue the player, which can upset the professional dynamic.

Free Agency

Players typically become free agents after accruing six years of MLB service time. As free agents, they can sign with any team, and this is often when the largest contracts are negotiated. Some of the biggest active contracts signed in Free Agency include Aaron Judge, 9 years, $360 million for the Yankees, and Bryce Harper, 13 years, $330 million with the Phillies. These numbers span the entire contract so Judge's annual salary is $40 million and Harper's just over $25 million.

Types of Contract

Unlike most other sports, MLB contracts are fully guaranteed, meaning if a player underperforms or suffers a serious injury, they are still entitled to the full contract amount. These contracts can also include performance bonuses to incentivize performance. These larger contracts may include elements such as extensions (negotiations for uncontracted years while the player is still under contract), no-trade clauses (restricts potential trades), or opt-out clauses (gives the player an option to opt out of the contract before the contract expires).

To Sum Up

MLB contracts, while potentially lucrative and career-defining, epitomize the cutthroat nature of professional sports. On one end, the allure of large, guaranteed contracts for star players and free agents represents the pinnacle of financial success in the sport. Yet, on the other end, the journey is marked by uncertainty and fierce competition. For players in the minor leagues and those navigating the early years of pre-arbitration, the path is fraught with low salaries, limited security, and the constant pressure to perform. Even as players reach arbitration and free agency, the negotiation process can be intense and unforgiving, influenced by a player's recent performance, potential, and the team's strategic considerations. This complex landscape of MLB contracts, from the initial minor league beginnings to the heights of multi-million dollar deals, underscores the highly competitive and business-oriented nature of Major League Baseball.


Adler, D. (2023, February 8). Here are the largest free-agent contracts in MLB history.

CBS Interactive. (2023, March 31). MLB approves First Contract for minor league players. CBS News.

OpenAI. (2023). ChatGPT (Nov 10 version) [Large language model].